Interpreting USP 800 Table 2 Primary Engineering Controls
Interpreting USP <800>
Table 2 Primary Engineering Controls
By Bryan Prince
USP
<800> is a relatively short document but packed with so much detail,
requiring quite a bit of technical thinking and explanation, especially as it
relates to the subject of engineering controls.
Pharmacists are not engineers, so one of the first questions is, how do
I interpret Table 2. Engineering Controls for Nonsterile HD Compounding?
First,
let’s dissect the two categories of engineering controls listed in Table
2. The “C-PEC” is the containment
primary engineering control, which is another name for a “powder hood”, also
called a containment ventilated enclosure (CVE). The table also lists other types of primary
engineering controls, but for the sake of this discussion we will only focus on
the most common type of hood found in a nonsterile compounding pharmacy.
The
C-PEC will have either one single HEPA filter (see Figure-1) or two HEPA
filters, also called “redundant-HEPA filtered” (see Figure-2). It is most likely your pharmacy’s older C-PECs
have only one single HEPA filter, because redundant HEPA filtered hoods have
only become popular for the past few years.
If your C-PEC has one single HEPA filter, then it will need to be
connected to an external blower, typically located on the roof of the
facility. It is important to note that the C-PEC’s
internal fan/blower does not have enough power to externally exhaust the air
out of the building without the help from another exhaust blower.
If your
pharmacy’s C-PEC has two HEPA filters like drawn in Figure-2, then you can
safely recirculate the clean air back into the lab. With this being said, it is possible that
some state boards of pharmacy will either not know how to interpret Table 2, or
outright refuse the recirculation of C-PECs in an HD room, so ultimately the
BOP will have final say on this topic.
The
containment secondary engineering control (C-SEC) is considered the hazardous
drug room, with fixed walls, segregating it from other nonhazardous compounding
and pharmacy activities. If the C-PECs
are connected to an external exhaust blower, then the C-PECs are contributing
to the C-SECs negative pressure. USP
<800> has listed a negative pressure differential for the HD room to be
-0.010 wc to -0.030” wc to adjacent spaces.
The problem with using a C-PEC to contribute to the C-SECs negative
pressure is that as the HEPA filter loads with particles, there will be a
pressure drop, which will cause the C-SECs negative pressure gradient to
fluctuate. Most C-PECs have a constant
volume motor which does not ramp up speed based on HEPA filter loading, which
is why it is better to use low wall exhaust grilles to externally vent the
C-SEC. If your pharmacy has multiple
C-PECs connected to an external exhaust blower, then it is likely the C-PECs
HEPA filters are going to load with particulate at differing timelines,
creating an interesting balance act of negative pressure. It is advised to utilize redundant HEPA
C-PECs in the HD nonsterile compounding rooms that recirculate to avoid
constant fluctuating room pressures.
As a
final note, the Figure-3 graphic shows a pre-filter and a HEPA filter in series
with each other, so it’s important to not think these qualify as redundant HEPA
filtered in series. Pre-filters are typically
“minimum efficiency reporting values” (MERV) rated filters which have particle
capture ratings of 50% up to 95% depending on the MERV rating. The takeaway here is that a HEPA filter has a
capture rating of 99.99%, therefore Figure-3 showing a MERV in series with a
single HEPA does not qualify for recirculation.
About the Author: Bryan Prince is the owner and lead consultant at Lab Red Pharmacy Consultants. His early career consisted of more than a decade in construction before moving to engineered containment serving the pharmaceutical industry and now the compounding industry. Since 2015 Bryan has designed and consulted on more than a hundred compounding pharmacies working with owners, architects, engineers, and contractors. Email: bryan@compoundingworkflow.com and watch videos https://compoundingworkflow.com
Comments
Post a Comment